ShipBob vs. ShipMonk: The Ultimate 3PL Comparison for eCommerce Fulfillment in 2024

Comparing Two Leading Third-Party Logistics Providers for eCommerce Brands

Choosing the right third-party logistics (3PL) provider is crucial for eCommerce businesses looking to streamline their order fulfillment process. Two popular options in the market are ShipBob and ShipMonk. In this comprehensive comparison, we'll examine the key differences between these providers, including their locations, services, pricing, and more, to help you make an informed decision for your business.

Understanding the Role of 3PL Providers

Before diving into the comparison, let's quickly review the role of 3PL providers in eCommerce fulfillment. A 3PL provider manages warehousing and order fulfillment on behalf of online retailers, offering benefits such as:

  • Access to a global network of fulfillment centers
  • Advanced technology for inventory management and order tracking
  • Discounted shipping rates through partnerships with carriers
  • Improved efficiency and accuracy in order processing
  • Scalability to support business growth

By partnering with a 3PL, eCommerce businesses can focus on their core competencies while leaving the complexities of fulfillment to the experts.

ShipBob vs. ShipMonk: Fulfillment Center Locations

One of the most critical factors in choosing a 3PL provider is their fulfillment center locations. A well-distributed network can significantly reduce shipping times and costs.

ShipBob's Global Fulfillment Network

ShipBob has a significant advantage in this area, with 13 fulfillment centers located across the United States, Canada, Europe, and Australia. This extensive global network allows them to offer fast 1-day delivery to many regions, providing a superior customer experience for eCommerce brands.

ShipMonk's US-Based Fulfillment Centers

In contrast, ShipMonk currently operates 3 fulfillment centers, all located within the United States. While they can efficiently handle domestic US deliveries, their lack of international presence may be a limitation for businesses looking to expand globally.

Comparing Fulfillment Services and Capabilities

Both ShipBob and ShipMonk offer a wide range of fulfillment services, including inventory receiving, storage, order picking and packing, and returns management. However, there are some notable differences in their capabilities:

ShipBob's Strengths

  • 1-day global shipping to major markets
  • Integrations with 50+ eCommerce platforms and marketplaces
  • Advanced analytics and reporting tools

ShipMonk's Specialties

  • Expertise in subscription box fulfillment
  • Kitting and assembly services for inventory management
  • Custom repacking and box customization options

When evaluating these services, consider your business's specific needs. If fast global delivery and extensive platform integrations are priorities, ShipBob may be the better choice. However, if you require specialized services like subscription box management or custom packaging, ShipMonk could be a more suitable fit.

Pricing Models and Fees: ShipBob vs. ShipMonk

Pricing is another critical consideration when selecting a 3PL partner. While both providers offer competitive rates, their pricing models differ:

ShipBob's Pricing Structure

  • Per-order pricing based on the number of items, weight, and dimensions
  • Free pick and pack services for high-volume businesses
  • Account setup and implementation fees
  • Higher storage fees for oversized items

ShipMonk's Pricing Model

  • Storage-based pricing, charged by the space used
  • Flat per-order pick and pack fee
  • $250 monthly minimum pick and pack fee
  • Additional fees for warehouse receiving and preparation

To determine which pricing model is most cost-effective for your business, carefully review your average order volume, item dimensions, and storage requirements. Don't forget to account for any additional fees or surcharges to avoid unexpected costs.

Service Level Agreements (SLAs) and Accountability

A service level agreement (SLA) outlines the standards and expectations for fulfillment performance, such as order processing times and accuracy rates. Having a clear SLA is crucial for holding your 3PL provider accountable.

ShipBob's Lack of Formal SLA

One potential drawback of partnering with ShipBob is their lack of a written SLA. Without formal commitments, it can be challenging to hold them responsible for delays or errors in order fulfillment.

ShipMonk's Documented SLA

ShipMonk, on the other hand, provides a documented SLA that outlines their fulfillment timeframes, accuracy rates, and order condition standards. While some users feel their SLA could be more aggressive, having a written agreement is still a significant advantage over ShipBob.

Evaluating the Pros and Cons

To summarize, here's a quick overview of the key advantages and limitations of each provider:

ShipBob Pros:

  • Extensive global fulfillment network
  • Integrations with numerous eCommerce platforms
  • Competitive pricing for high-volume businesses

ShipBob Cons:

  • No formal SLA or performance guarantees
  • Various account fees and surcharges
  • Inconsistent support for low-volume businesses

ShipMonk Pros:

  • Specialization in subscription box fulfillment
  • Kitting and custom packaging options
  • Predictable storage-based pricing model

ShipMonk Cons:

  • Limited international fulfillment capabilities
  • Monthly minimum pick and pack fee
  • Weak guarantees for delivery timeliness

Making the Right Choice for Your eCommerce Business

Ultimately, the decision between ShipBob and ShipMonk depends on your unique fulfillment needs and business goals. Consider the following questions to guide your decision:

  • Do you require global fulfillment capabilities?
  • What is your average monthly order volume?
  • Is 1-day delivery a priority for your customers?
  • Do you anticipate rapid growth in your product catalog and inventory?
  • Are integrations with specific eCommerce platforms essential?
  • Do you need specialized services like kitting or custom packaging?

By carefully evaluating your answers to these questions and weighing the strengths and weaknesses of each provider, you can make an informed decision that sets your eCommerce business up for long-term success.


Choosing the right 3PL provider is a critical decision that can significantly impact your eCommerce business's growth and profitability. By comparing ShipBob and ShipMonk across key factors like location, services, pricing, and SLAs, you can determine which provider aligns best with your fulfillment needs and goals.

Remember, the ideal 3PL partner should not only meet your current requirements but also have the flexibility and scalability to support your business as it grows. Take the time to thoroughly research and compare your options to find the perfect fit for your eCommerce fulfillment needs.

Looking for eCommerce fulfillment partner?

Let's Chat