Three things break items in transit: the item could move inside the box, the box could flex, or the cushioning was thinner than the carrier's own packing guide asks for. Fix those first. Then get the paperwork right, so you have a claim worth filing when one still breaks; that is the part most packing guides leave out.
The short version
- Protect the surface first where bubble wrap should not touch it: a cover sheet over a painted canvas, a sleeve over a print, tape or film over glass. The item-by-item section below says what to use.
- Then wrap every piece on its own in at least 3 inches of bubble wrap, flat side against the item, and tape the wrap to itself rather than to the piece.
- Put 2 to 3 inches of firm cushioning on every side, close the box and shake it. If anything moves or rattles, open it and add more.
- Double-box anything you would be sorry to lose: the wrapped item in a snug inner box, that box inside an outer box with 3 inches of cushioning all the way around.
- Tape the center seam and both edge seams in an H. Put the label on the largest face, away from the seams, and drop a second label inside.
- Declare the value on anything worth more than $100. On a U.S. domestic package that is where UPS and FedEx liability stops unless you pay for more, and where the insurance included with USPS Ground Advantage and Priority Mail ends.
- If one does break, have the customer keep the box and everything in it until the claim is settled. USPS denies a claim when the packaging is gone, and FedEx asks for it to be kept too.
The rest of this guide is the detail: what each carrier covers, why claims get denied, and how the method changes for ceramics, glass, framed art, canvas and prints.
What UPS, FedEx and USPS cover when something breaks
The number to remember is $100. On a U.S. domestic package, all three carriers include some cover for loss or damage up to that amount in the base price, but it pays only on an approved claim: filed inside the window, with proof of value, the packaging available for inspection and, for USPS, packing that passes the rules in the next section. Above it, you have to declare a value or buy insurance, and two of the three cap what you can declare on exactly the products this page is about. Everything in this section describes U.S. domestic shipments; international terms and deadlines differ.
Carrier | Liability on a U.S. domestic package if you declare nothing | Most you can declare | The catch |
|---|---|---|---|
UPS | $100 per package | $50,000 per package | Declaring more than $100 "does not receive any form of insurance"; start a damage claim within 60 days of the scheduled delivery |
FedEx | $100 per package | $50,000 for Express and Ground, but only $1,000 for artwork, glassware, ceramics, porcelain, framed glass, antiques and photographs | FedEx states it does not provide insurance of any kind; file within 60 calendar days of the ship date for a U.S. package |
USPS | Up to $100 included with Ground Advantage, Priority Mail and Priority Mail Express when the package has a USPS tracking barcode | $5,000 with purchased insurance, priced by coverage band ($4.50 for $100.01 to $200) | File within 60 days of mailing; a claim is denied if the item was packed so that it could not have arrived undamaged |
The UPS tariff limits UPS's liability to $100 per domestic package unless you declare a higher value and pay for it, up to $50,000 per package, and says plainly that a shipper who declares more than $100 "does not receive any form of insurance". Declared value raises the cap on what UPS will pay out when UPS is at fault. It is not a policy, and UPS points shippers who want actual insurance to a third party.
The FedEx Service Guide has the same $100 default and the same $50,000 ceiling for Express and Ground, and then a list that matters for anyone reading this page. Shipments containing artwork (paintings, drawings, vases, limited-edition prints, sculpture), glassware (ceramics, porcelain, china, crystal, mirrors, framed glass "and any other commodity with similarly fragile qualities"), antiques or photographs are limited to a maximum declared value of $1,000. A $2,500 framed print cannot be covered past $1,000 on a FedEx label, whatever you pay. The same section says, in capitals, that FedEx does not provide insurance coverage of any kind, and the declared value page repeats that "declared value is not shipping insurance". For U.S. package services the charge is $4.95 for a declared value between $100.01 and $300, then $1.65 per $100 above $300.
USPS works differently. Ground Advantage, Priority Mail and Priority Mail Express include up to $100 of insurance in the price, provided the package carries a USPS tracking barcode, and you can buy more, up to $5,000. The fee depends on how much coverage the package carries in total: on the current USPS price list, a package insured for $100.01 to $200 costs $4.50, $200.01 to $300 costs $4.55, and the fee climbs by band to $9.05 plus $1.50 per $100 over $600 at the top. It is real insurance rather than a liability cap, but it pays under the claim rules in the next section, and those rules are strict about packaging.
The practical rule for a brand: if the sale price is over $100, declared value or insurance has to be part of the label cost, or you are self-insuring and should price for it. If the item is art, glass or ceramic and worth more than $1,000, FedEx cannot cover it in full, so the choice is UPS with declared value, USPS with purchased insurance, or a third-party policy. Our shipping insurance guide covers the third-party options and the cost math.
Why damage claims get denied
The USPS claim rules in Domestic Mail Manual section 609 are public, and they are the clearest statement of how a carrier thinks about a broken package. Claims that are not payable include:
- "Damage by abrasion, scarring, or scraping to articles not properly wrapped for protection."
- "Fragile nature of article prevented its safe carriage in the mail, regardless of packaging."
- Any item "packaged in such a manner that it could not have reached its destination undamaged."
- "Damage caused by shock, transportation environment, or x-ray, without evidence of damage to the mailing container."
Read those together and the pattern is clear: a broken item inside an undamaged box is the case USPS is most likely to treat as a packing failure, so expect the claim to turn on how the piece was wrapped rather than on how the carrier handled it. Two more rules in the same section catch sellers out. Damage claims must be filed within 60 days of the mailing date, and the addressee has to keep the mailing container, the damaged item and all of the packaging for inspection; the manual says that "failure to do so will result in denial of the claim". You also need proof of value, such as a sales receipt, an invoice or a card statement showing what was paid.
FedEx and UPS publish less about their reasons, but the rules you can see have the same shape. For U.S. packages, FedEx asks you to file damage claims within 60 calendar days of the shipment date (international packages get 21), and to keep the original packaging and contents until the claim is resolved. UPS wants the claim started within 60 days of the scheduled delivery. All three windows are short and each is measured from a different date, so the safe habit is to file in the same week the customer tells you.
What that means for how you run things:
- Photograph the packed box before you seal it, once per product rather than per order, so you can show how a SKU is packed when a claim comes up.
- Put a slip in the box telling the customer what to do if it arrives broken: photograph the box and the item, keep everything, and email you within a few days.
- Keep the invoice or order record for every shipment you declared a value on. A claim without proof of value stalls.
- File quickly, and file before you ship the replacement if you can, so the customer still has the original packaging in hand.
The packing method carriers actually describe
Carriers publish their own packing guides, and USPS's claim rules turn on whether an item was properly packed, so this section follows FedEx's guide to packing breakables and UPS's packaging tips rather than folklore.
Materials
- Box. A new double-wall corrugated box, sturdy enough to carry the weight of what is inside, which is FedEx's one stated requirement. A box that has already been through the carrier network once may have lost some of its crush strength, and a box with a split seam will flex. Corrugated liners and inserts add strength, which UPS notes in its guide.
- Bubble wrap. FedEx asks for a minimum 3-inch thickness of air-cellular cushioning around each fragile item. UPS says to wrap with the flat side against the product, bubbles facing away. A lot of advice online says the opposite; follow the carrier's version.
- Packing peanuts. UPS wants at least 2 inches of loose fill around lightweight items, and warns that peanuts are not ideal for flat, narrow products that can work their way through them. Polystyrene also builds static, so electronics need anti-static foam instead.
- Crumpled kraft paper. UPS calls it void fill for lightweight, non-fragile items. It is fine for filling the last gap, not for cushioning a vase. Where you use it, keep at least 2 inches between the contents and the outer box, tightly crumpled.
- Air pillows. Void fill for items without sharp corners or edges. UPS notes that extreme heat or cold can affect how well they protect.
- Cell dividers and foam inserts. The only sensible way to ship a set. Every piece gets its own cell, and nothing touches anything else.
- Tape. Pressure-sensitive packing tape wide enough to cover each seam with margin to spare. Masking tape, duct tape and cellophane tape fail or leave residue.
The method
- Cover any surface that bubble wrap should not touch: a cover sheet over paint, a sleeve over a print, tape or film over glass, as described by item type below. Then wrap each piece individually in 3 inches of bubble wrap, flat side in, and tape the wrap to itself. Never tape to the item.
- Line the bottom of the box with 2 to 3 inches of firm cushioning, stand the piece in the middle, and make sure nothing touches a wall or another piece. Heaviest items go lowest.
- Fill every gap, close the box and shake it. If you hear or feel movement, open it and add cushioning until you do not.
- For anything you would hate to replace, double-box. UPS's two-box method calls for an outer box 6 inches larger in depth, width and length than the inner one, with 3 inches of cushioning filling the space between them.
- Seal with H-tape: one strip down the center seam and one along each edge seam, top and bottom.
- Put the label on the largest face, not across a taped seam, and put a duplicate address label inside the box. If the item has a right way up, add orientation arrows.
A word on fragile stickers. Neither FedEx's packing page nor UPS's packaging tips say that a "Fragile" marking changes how a package is handled, and nothing in the claim rules quoted on this page gives you credit for one. Use them, they cost nothing, but build the box as if nobody will read them.
Packing by item type
The method above is the baseline. What changes by product is where the weak points are and what has to touch the surface.
Ceramics and pottery
Porcelain and bone china are thin-walled and chip at rims and feet. Stoneware and earthenware are thicker but crack along stress lines when they are knocked rather than dropped. Either way, the rule is to support the piece from both sides: stuff hollow pieces with tissue or kraft paper so the inside wall is braced, then wrap the outside. Wrap handles, spouts, knobs and feet separately before wrapping the whole piece, since those are the parts that snap. Take lids off and wrap them on their own; a lid left loose inside its pot is a hammer. Plates and tiles travel better standing on edge than stacked flat, with a piece of cardboard between each. For sets, use a cell divider and give every piece its own cell.
Glassware, stemware and candle jars
Stemware breaks at the stem, so wrap the stem first, then fill the bowl with tissue, then wrap the whole glass. Tumblers and jars get stuffed and wrapped the same way. Use a cell divider for anything shipped in multiples, and never let two pieces of glass touch through a single layer of wrap. A candle in a glass vessel is glassware as far as packing is concerned, so treat it like a jar, and keep the lid taped on so it cannot rattle against the glass.
Framed art and anything under glass
Run painter's tape in an X across the glass, or wrap the whole glazed face in stretch film, so that if the glass does break the shards stay put instead of sliding across the print. Fit cardboard corner protectors to the frame, sandwich the piece between two sheets of rigid cardboard larger than the frame, then wrap in bubble and box it with 2 to 3 inches of cushioning on every side. Ship it standing on edge, not flat, and mark the box so it stays that way. If you ship framed work regularly, glaze with acrylic instead of glass; it weighs less and does not shatter. For claims, remember that framed glass and limited-edition prints both sit inside FedEx's $1,000 declared-value cap.
Canvas paintings
Give the paint time to cure before anything touches it, and treat "dry to the touch" as the start of that clock. Golden's drying notes say a thin acrylic film can be fully dry in a few days while thick passages take weeks or more, and that until then nothing but air should touch the surface, because glassine, paper, bubble wrap and plastic can all stick to it or leave an imprint. Oil is slower, and the paint makers publish drying milestones rather than shipping dates. Winsor & Newton puts touch-dry at 2 to 12 days depending on the pigment, and touch-dry is only the surface. Gamblin does not call a painting ready for varnish until it is dry to the touch and firm in its thickest areas, which it puts at 2 to 3 weeks for a thinly painted canvas and 1 to 2 months for a thick one, checked by pressing a fingernail into the heaviest paint. None of that is a wrap-ready date; what it tells you is that oil stays soft for weeks after it feels dry. Wait at least until the paint passes that firmness check, then ship it with as little touching the painted face as the method below allows.
Once it is cured, cover the painted face before any cushioning goes on. For acrylics, Golden's advice for shipping is that nothing touching the surface is safest, and where something must, a sheet of thick polyethylene (4 mil or more) or silicone release paper is less likely to stick than glassine, which tore and stuck in places in its rolling tests. Those tests were on acrylic; there is no equivalent published test for oil, so the cautious choice is the same non-stick cover and as little contact as possible. Hold the cover with artist's tape at the back, never on the paint, then bubble wrap with the flat side in, corner protectors and a box with 2 to 3 inches of cushioning. Protect the back of a stretched canvas as well; a poke from behind leaves a dent in the front.
Rolling a large unframed canvas is cheaper to ship, not safer. Golden says rolling is not its best recommendation: it can imprint or ferrotype the surface, interleaving can stick, cold paint can crack, and its rolling method assumes a climate-controlled room and a relatively thinly painted acrylic. If the cost case wins anyway and the painting is a cured, thinly painted acrylic, roll it paint side out, face down on release paper or polyethylene, around the widest tube you can get (Golden suggests at least 6 inches across) so the paint layer is stretched rather than compressed, leave a margin of material past the painted edges, and ship it in a rigid tube with end caps. Never roll a canvas that is still curing; it will set in the rolled shape. Acrylic stiffens in the cold and can crack if it is flexed, so a winter shipment travels better flat. The sources on this page do not cover rolling oil paintings; ship those flat. If a buyer asks for a rolled canvas to frame locally, explain that tradeoff before you agree.
Prints, photographs and paper
Handle glossy prints with cotton or nitrile gloves. Sleeve each print in glassine or a clear bag, sandwich it between two sheets of rigid board larger than the print, and ship it in a rigid mailer a size up from the boards, so the edges of the print are not the first thing to take a knock, or rolled around a core inside a tube for larger sizes. "Do not bend" is a label, not a structure; the board is what stops the bend.
Sculpture and heavy pieces
Heavy pieces want foam cut to shape inside a double box, or a crate. Know what that costs before you quote shipping: UPS treats any package that is not a fully encased corrugated box, or that is longer than 48 inches or heavier than 70 pounds, as an irregular parcel that needs special handling and may incur extra fees. Neither FedEx's nor UPS's packing guidance sets a weight above which a sculpture has to be crated; crate it because a dropped stone or bronze piece breaks itself and anything near it. For the size and weight rules, see our guide to UPS shipping rules.
Electronics
Static is the second threat. Wrap in an anti-static bag or anti-static foam first, then bubble, and use the original retail box inside a shipping box where you still have it. Keep 2 inches of cushioning on every side and label the orientation. If electronics are a big part of what you sell, our electronics fulfillment page covers the handling side.
What a broken order actually costs
A damaged order is never just the product. Take a $45 ceramic mug as an example: the replacement unit, a second round of packaging, a second postage charge, the first postage, which you do not get back if the claim is denied, and the half hour spent on photos, emails and the claim form. Add those up and a single break can wipe out the margin on the order before any review is written. Run that arithmetic on your own breakage rate and the real cost of thin packaging is usually bigger than the cost of the extra 2 inches of cushioning.
If you pack repeat products yourself, the fix is standardization rather than heroics: one box size per SKU, pre-cut inserts or a cell divider, a written pack spec with a photo, and the same person checking the shake test every time. Our comparison of in-house fulfillment and a 3PL walks through what that time is worth.
When the packing hour and the claims paperwork become the bottleneck, that is a reasonable point to hand fulfillment off. A warehouse packs the same SKU the same way every day, which is what keeps breakage down. At Simpl, fragile orders ship in right-sized protective packaging, with custom packaging for items that need it; tell us about your fragile formats during onboarding and we match the packaging to them. Our breakage rate is near zero. We file the carrier claim for any package we shipped that arrives lost or damaged, and insured shipping is available, with coverage and declared value depending on the carrier. Our fragile product fulfillment page has the detail, and pricing explains the flat per-order rate, which includes the packaging.
If you want the cushioning itself to be recyclable or compostable, paper bubble, molded pulp and cornstarch peanuts all exist; our guide to eco-friendly packaging materials compares them.
