How to Deal with Broken Items: Buyers and Sellers Guide

Returning or exchanging a broken item can be a hassle. Follow these tips to make the process as smooth as possible for everyone involved.

How to Deal with Broken Items: Buyers and Sellers Guide

Customers who receive broken or faulty products tend to return them. Here, it is essential to identify the main reason behind the defective or damaged products. Thus, this post has highlighted how items get damaged, how sellers and buyers can deal with broken things, filing a claim with the carrier, tips to prevent broken products, and the actions you should take when the product gets lost in transit.

How Do Products Get Damaged?

There are many reasons behind the receiving of damaged materials or goods by your customers. It may include:

Bad weather conditions

 Many products can be damaged or broken due to rough weather conditions, such as heavy rain and strong winds. This is especially true for items transported via truck or ship, as exposure to bad weather can cause damage to the shipment itself or the individual products within it.

Poor handling during transportation

In addition to bad weather, damaged products can also result from poor handling during transport. This may include rough handling by warehouse staff or delivery personnel or being damaged during transit due to inadequate packaging.

Improper storage

 Finally, damaged products often occur due to unsuitable storage. This may involve storing items in insecure or unstable locations that expose them to damage from outside forces. It can also include storing products in high temperatures or humidity levels that cause them to degrade over time.

Inadequate packaging material

One of the most common causes of damaged or broken products is using harmful packaging materials. This can include choosing low-quality materials, like cardboard or bubble wrap, that are more prone to tearing and damage. It can also involve insufficient protective material, resulting in a shipment being damaged during transit.

Wear and tear

While damaged products may often result from external factors, it is also essential to consider factors from within. For example, damaged items can also be caused by normal wear and tear over time. This may include breakage due to weakened or damaged components or damage due to general use and age.

How Can Buyers Deal with Broken Items?

Buyers need to follow the given steps to deal with returning damaged items.

Accepting The Damaged Merchandise

Although damaged products can be frustrating, it is essential to remember that there are steps you can take to minimize the impact on your business. One option is simply accepting the damaged items and dealing with them as-is, either by returning them to the manufacturer or reselling them at a discounted price.

Requesting A Replacement

Alternatively, some buyers may request a replacement item from the seller or manufacturer. This allows you to get an undamaged product while potentially getting compensation for any inconvenience caused by damaged goods.

Document The Damage

Regardless of the course of action you take to deal with damaged items, it is essential to document any damage. This can involve taking photos or video footage of the damaged goods and keeping records of communication between yourself and the seller or manufacturer. Having this information will be helpful if there are any disputes or returns down the line.

Returning Damaged Items

 Finally, if you cannot accept damaged products or do not want additional replacements, you may choose to return damaged items to the seller or manufacturer instead. While this

Related: eCommerce Returns: 7 Best Practices For Smart Businesses

Contact Your Seller

The first step in returning damaged items is to contact your seller or manufacturer directly. This may include sending an email or submitting a request through their online customer service portal. Be sure to clearly explain the nature of the damaged goods and any compensation you request, if applicable.

Fill Out Returns Paperwork

Depending on the seller or manufacturer's policies, you may be asked to complete return paperwork before returning damaged goods. This can include completing a detailed description of damaged products and providing receipts or other documentation showing proof of purchase.

Prepare Your Shipment

Once you have received confirmation that damaged goods can be returned and have completed all necessary paperwork, it is essential to properly prepare your shipment for transit back to the seller or manufacturer. This may include packing damaged items in suitable packaging materials, such as bubble wrap or cardboard boxes, to prevent any additional damage during transit. It would help if you also consider insuring your shipment for peace of mind in case of potential mishaps.

How Can Sellers Deal with Broken Items?

When the buyer notifies the damaged goods or products, then the seller needs to do one of the following things;

Initiate A Full Refund To The Customer

 As a seller, one of the most straightforward ways to deal with damaged products is simply to refund your customers in full for the damaged items. This allows you to avoid any further inconvenience or hassle and can help build customer trust and loyalty over time.

Offer Discounts Or Coupons

 Another option is to offer your customers compensation, such as discounts on future purchases or coupons for free shipping. This may encourage buyers unhappy with damaged goods to continue shopping with your business in the future.

Related: Ultimate Guide To Coupons And Promotions For Amazon

Consider Replacement Options

You may offer damaged item replacements or refunds depending on your return policies and product availability. This can be an excellent way to keep buyers and sellers happy by ensuring that broken items are replaced with undamaged ones.

Provide A Partial Refund

Alternatively, you may provide damaged items to customers with a partial refund instead of a full one. This can help compensate buyers for any inconvenience or loss in value related to damaged goods while also protecting your business's bottom line.

Ultimately, there are many different ways that sellers and manufacturers can deal with damaged products, and the right course of action will depend on a variety of factors, including customer expectations, product availability, and company policies. Being strategic and transparent in your approach to damaged items can help minimize the impact on both buyers and sellers.

What To Do If An Item Is Damaged During Shipping?

If you receive damaged items during shipping, your first step should be to contact the seller or manufacturer as soon as possible. This may involve emailing or submitting a request through their online customer service portal.

In your communication with the seller or manufacturer, clearly describe the damaged goods and any losses or damages you have incurred as a result. Depending on the situation, you may also want to ask about potential replacement options for damaged items, such as refunds, discounts, or replacements.

Once you have received confirmation from the seller or manufacturer that damaged goods can be returned and refunded, it is essential to prepare your shipment for transit back to them appropriately. This may involve using suitable packaging materials like bubble wrap or cardboard boxes to prevent additional damage during transit. You may also want to consider insuring your shipment for peace of mind.

Ultimately, the best course of action will depend on various factors, including the specific damaged items and your return policies or product availability. By being proactive and transparent in your approach to damaged goods, however, you can help minimize the impact on both yourself and your customers.​

How To File A Claim With The Carrier?

One of the most common ways products gets damaged is through shipping mishaps. If your shipment arrives damaged or you notice that some items have been injured while in transit, filing a claim with the carrier is essential.

To begin the process, you'll need to gather all relevant documentation related to the damaged items and shipments. This might include photos of the damaged products and any notes or delivery records from when your order was delivered. You will also need to contact your carrier directly and provide them with this information so that they can begin assessing your claim.

Once you've submitted all of the necessary documentation, it's generally up to the carrier to assess and process your claim within a specific time frame. This might involve inspecting and repairing damaged goods or simply providing you with a refund for the damaged items.

In some cases, it may also be necessary to reach out to your seller or manufacturer if they are responsible for the damaged product. If this is the case, try contacting them directly to discuss what options are available and how you can proceed with filing a claim.

If you find that your carrier is not processing your claim promptly or isn't giving you the support you need, it's essential to take further action by seeking legal assistance. Some professionals specialize in helping businesses navigate shipping claims and other disputes with carriers, so don't hesitate to speak with them if needed. Ultimately, it's essential to do everything you can to protect your damaged products and ensure that you are fairly compensated for any losses.

Related: USPS Lost My Package: What Do I Do?

Tips to Prevent Damaged Goods Items

To prevent damaged goods items, you can focus on specific steps like;

Proper Packing Of The Product

One of the most important things to consider when shipping damaged goods are how you pack the item. You should always use sturdy packaging materials, such as bubble wrap or sturdy boxes, to protect your product from getting damaged during shipment.

Go Through Some Packaging Testing

Another effective way to prevent damaged goods is by testing different types of packaging before sending out your product. This can involve shipping the item to yourself to see how well it holds up during transit or working with a packaging professional who can advise you on the best options for protecting your product from damage.

Invest In Good Packaging Materials

In addition to testing different packaging materials, it is also essential to invest in high-quality materials that can help protect your product from external forces. This may involve using special tape, packing peanuts for fragile items, or using foam inserts and other cushioning materials for more durable products.

Get Insurance For Your Shipment

If you are concerned about the possibility of damaged goods, it may be worth looking into insurance for your shipment. This will protect your items in case anything goes wrong during transit and give you peace of mind when shipping your products to customers or clients.

Prefer A Reliable Courier

When shipping damaged goods, it is also essential to consider the reliability and experience of your courier. By choosing a reputable and established courier service, you can minimize the chances that your products will get damaged during transit and ensure that they arrive at their destination in good condition.

Provide An Exchange Option Instead Of Returns

If your products are prone to damage, offering an exchange option instead of returns may be a good idea. This will allow customers to replace damaged goods rather than refunding their money, and it can help minimize any negative impact on your business due to damaged goods.

An Airtight Return Policy For Damaged Items

To ensure that your customers are protected if their damaged goods arrive, it is essential to have an airtight return policy in place. This should include clear instructions on how to report damaged items, how you will process returns, and any restocking fees or other policies that may apply. With a transparent and fair return policy for damaged items, your customers can be confident in buying from your company.

Set An Appropriate Return Timeline 

To ensure that damaged goods can be processed quickly, setting an appropriate return timeline is essential. This should consider both the condition of the damaged item and how long it took to arrive at its destination. For example, you may consider offering a faster exchange process for items damaged during transit but still in good condition while allowing more time for damaged items that arrived weeks or months ago. Setting clear timelines for damaged goods can help minimize any negative impact on your customers and business.

Ensure Good Customer Service And Communication

In addition to having the right policies and processes for damaged goods, it is also essential to focus on providing good customer service and communication. This may involve regularly updating customers on the status of their damaged items, responding quickly to any inquiries or complaints, and taking steps to resolve damaged goods as quickly and efficiently as possible. Focusing on excellent customer service throughout the process can help reduce negative feelings toward damaged goods and build a loyal customer base.

Always Ask For The Packaging And Item

When dealing with damaged goods, it is essential to ask for the packaging and item in question so that you can assess the damage and determine whether or not it is worth fixing. This will help you avoid any unnecessary refunds or replacements and allow you to get a more accurate estimate of damaged items in the future. Ensuring that damaged goods are thoroughly assessed can help minimize any negative impact on your business.

What To Do If An Item Is Lost In Transit?

If the product is lost in transit, then follow the tips;

Check Your Given Shipping Address Is Right

The first thing to do if an item appears to be lost in transit is to check that your given shipping address is correct. This will help you rule out any potential issues with the delivery, such as incorrect or incomplete information from the courier service.

Contact Customer Service

If you still cannot locate your shipment after checking your address, it may be a good idea to contact customer service for further assistance. They may be able to provide more information about the status of your order or point you in the right direction so that you can get your lost items back.

Ask For Proof Of Delivery

 In some cases, it may also be helpful to ask for proof of delivery before determining whether an item is considered "lost." This can help you confirm that the shipment has left your possession and is no longer under your control.

Check Around Your Building Or Home

 If you suspect an item may be lost in transit, it is also a good idea to check around your building or home for any signs of the package. This can include looking in common areas such as lobbies or mailrooms and scanning your surrounding neighborhood for any packages left on porches, doorsteps, or other public spaces.

Call Your Local Post Office

In some cases, items may not just be "lost" in transit - they may have been delivered to the wrong address. If you suspect this is the case with your lost shipment, it may be worth calling your local post office to see if they might have additional information about where and when the package was delivered. While there is no guarantee that they will be able to help, it may be worth a shot to try and get your lost items back.

Check For The Attempted Delivery Notice

In some cases, items lost in transit may have been delivered to the intended recipient but not picked up. To determine whether this is the case with your shipment, it can be helpful to check for an attempted delivery notice from the courier service or postal service. This will give you a better idea of when and where your items were delivered, which can help you track down any missing packages more quickly.

Notify Your Insurance Company

Suppose you suspect one or more of your damaged goods may have been damaged during transit due to poor packaging or another external factor. In that case, it is a good idea to notify your insurance company immediately. They will be able to assess the situation and provide assistance as needed, such as covering damaged items, helping you to file a claim with the courier service, or providing other support as required.

Check Your Mailbox

If you have not yet seen any signs of your lost shipment, it may be worth checking your mailbox for any potential delivery notifications or other information. This can help you to rule out the possibility that your items were delivered but misplaced or overlooked by someone in your household.

 Wait For 6 Days

 Finally, if your item still does not appear after six days, it is generally recommended that you wait a bit longer before making any final decisions. There may be additional delays or issues with the delivery service that could still cause your shipment to turn up eventually. By being patient and giving yourself time to look into the situation further, you can ensure that you have exhausted all options before moving on.

Take Steps To Prevent Future Damaged Shipments

In addition to taking these immediate steps if your damaged goods appear to be missing or lost in transit, it is also essential to consider ways to prevent this from happening again. Some possible solutions may include investing in better packaging materials or courier services, learning from past mistakes, and working with your customers to find better solutions for damaged items. By taking a proactive approach to damaged goods, you can minimize their impact on your business and customers.

Overall, buyers and sellers should be more careful when dealing with broken items. However, following the given tips can help prevent damaged goods quickly and straightforwardly. 


Returning or exchanging a broken item can be a hassle, but with this guide, you'll know exactly what to do. If you have questions or need help fulfilling Amazon orders, don't hesitate to contact Simpl. We're here to make the process as smooth and easy for you as possible.

Recommended: How To Outsource Pick Pack And Ship

Looking for eCommerce fulfillment partner?

Let's Chat

Looking for a FBA Prep Partner?

Let's Chat